You are here
Home > News > An epic battle of the holiday mayonnaise salads

An epic battle of the holiday mayonnaise salads

According to several people polled by Eastern Door reporter Jessica Deer, Dustin’s Convenience has the best potato and macaroni salad in town. (Jessica Deer, The Eastern Door)

Whether you love it or hate it, mayonnaise-based salads are a staple on Kahnawake dinner tables for special occasions, and the holidays are no exception.

My family, like many others in town, always have a bowl of potato salad and macaroni salad on the kitchen countertop ready to spoon heaps onto your plate during Christmas dinner.

At least with the recipes my family makes, they barely look indistinguishable from each other. There are eggs, a lot of mayo, and either boiled potatoes or boiled noodles.

It’s pretty much like you’re eating the same thing, right? WRONG.

Allegiances for either one run deep, fierce, and this week, in a totally unscientific poll, The Eastern Door wanted to find out which salad really prevails in the hearts and stomachs of Kahnawa’kehró:non and other Onkwehón:we in the surrounding communities.

“Macaroni salad is much better than potato salad,” said K103 Radio afternoon host Dennen Phillips.

Wayne Robinson, an intervention worker at Native Montreal, had similar sentiments.

“Potato salad is for peasants,” he said.

Neither really elaborated their despise for potatoes, but well, neither did any of the spud supporters I talked to.

“When it’s good, it’s better than anything,” said Cory Phillips about the taters.

For an entire week, I had a poll on Facebook asking which people prefer to eat during the holidays.

“These are the important questions of our lives,” said J.D. Saylor.

He may have been being sarcastic, but yes, it is totally important. When one has to unbutton their jeans at the end of Christmas dinner because there’s so much food to choose from, important decisions need to be made, and one dense glop of mayonnaise-smothered substance just might not make the cut on everybody’s plate.

“Mac salad just goes better with turkey, gravy and mashed potatoes,” said Myrna Gabriel.

Um. Potatoes and potatoes go great with each other, obviously, and it was proven in the early days of the poll. However, out of the shadows emerged macaroni admirers, taking a 53 percent victory in the last hours of the poll.

“How is macaroni pulling ahead? The vote is rigged,” said Jennifer Brazeau.

She wasn’t the only one rightfully upset with the results.

“All this shows is that 53 percent of people made a poor choice,” said Orin Loft.

“I am surprised and disappointed,” added spud supporter Brianna Montour.

Others had a more peaceful, wholesome, and indecisive view on the dinner choices.

“I love both of them,” said Maylan Jacobs.

Former Eastern Door intern Franca Mignacca also wanted to vote for both.

“This choice is impossible,” she said.

Not only were strong potato and macaroni fans vocal, but the loudest of them all were those who despise both.

“What? No carrot Jell-O on the list of gross things no one should eat but always wind up at a church pot luck?” Eastern Door assistant editor Daniel J. Rowe asked.

Not surprisingly, many also vocalized their preference for coleslaw, or a salad with actual leafy greens.

“They’re both equally disgusting,” said my sister Brooke Deer.

[email protected]

Dear Readers:

As an essential service that is still open during the COVID-19 pandemic, The Eastern Door is fighting hard to keep news like this flowing, in our print product, though an online subscription at and here, for free, on our website and Facebook.

But when a large portion of our regular revenue has disappeared due to so many other businesses being closed, our circulation being affected by the same issue, and all of our specials canceled until the end of the year, we are looking for alternative ways to keep operations going, staff paid, and the paper out every Friday for you to enjoy.

Please consider a financial contribution to help us keep doing what we do best; telling the stories of our people in a contemporary medium – a solid, continuing archive that documents our cherished, shared history. Your kind donation will go to a newspaper that stands as the historical record, in-depth, informative and award-winning news; colourful stories, and a big boost to the local economy by employing 95 percent local workers.

Also, please consider subscribing to our e-edition, which comes out Thursday night, at today, or pick up your copy Friday morning in Kahnawake, Kanesatake or Chateauguay. Akwesasne delivery has been suspended due to the pandemic and border issues.

We exercise real freedom of the press every single day. Without our reporters fighting for the truth our community would be missing a whole lot of facts, separated from gossip and rumors.

E-transfers are accepted and very much appreciated at: [email protected]