You are here
Home > Arts & Culture > Price Paid delivers a critical study of First Nations law and politics

Price Paid delivers a critical study of First Nations law and politics

Price Paid: the Fight for First Nations Survival is the second book by Bev Sellars, a scholar of both history and law for First Nations.

A residential school survivor herself, she is a former chief of the Soda Creek Nation in Williams Lake, British Columbia. Her account of colonialism’s effect on Canada’s First Nations is part history lesson, part law study and part memoir.

“What if you owned a house and beautiful garden? Would you share it with others? Would you welcome them?” The opening words of the book explain the fateful mistrust that was placed in the colonists, which Sellars refers to as ‘newcomers’.

The first chapter titled ‘Indian Givers’ is in reference to the many contributions made by the First Nations to the modern world. For example, European staples such as tomatoes, potatoes and chocolate all originated in the Americas. The miracle material now known as rubber was a product first created by First Nations in Mexico and Central America.

Sellars documents the very real ‘clash of cultures’ between First Nations and the newcomers. Concepts of gift giving, property rights and equality of the sexes meant very different things for the two groups.

“Between 67.5 and 106.4 million Aboriginal people died. You don’t see that in the history books,” she writes.

This is one of the most powerful phrases of the book and is an important fact with respect to calculating the damage done during colonization.

With that in mind the book is an excellent introduction for anyone wanting to learn about First Nations politics and law in Canada. Sellars highlights political and social consequences of the infamous Indian Act, and how reserves were forced to accept the Band Council system. It is written how community members would often elect traditional chiefs but the Indian Act would then be changed so that the Department of Indian Affairs could annul any election it didn’t approve of.

Writing about WWII veterans, she explains how First Nations veterans were disenfranchised after serving in the Canadian Army. This occurred because they were either disenfranchised when they enlisted or because they were away from the reserve for over four years. At that point they could actually be charged with trespassing on a reserve!

A fascinating chapter was written by her husband Bill Wilson, also a former chief. He documents his meeting to discuss Section 35 of the Constitution Act 1982, which was for Aboriginal rights. There he met colorful figures such as former prime minister Pierre Elliot Trudeau and former Quebec premier René Lévesque, as well as the other premiers of the time.

“The Aboriginal leaders, the prime minister, premier Lévesque, and premier Richard Hatfield from New Brunswick were the only ones who had a clue about the importance of the discussions” Wilson writes.

In later chapters Sellars describes the challenges she faced serving as a chief in her own home reserve. Housing was badly affected by mold, sometimes killing the elderly. Landslides forced some people out of their homes and the local waterways were polluted by industrial and agricultural activity. Population size is on the decline.

“They do not understand that any human would have the same social problems if treated in the same way,” she writes.

This book is meant to do just that, show how the reserve structure holds people back and keeps them in a loop of failure. The book can be depressing to read at times, which is a good thing since it calls on reflection from all Canadians. Overall it combines legal and historical knowledge into a single compact book that should be read by all Canadians.


Dear Readers:

As an essential service that is still open during the COVID-19 pandemic, The Eastern Door is fighting hard to keep news like this flowing, in our print product, though an online subscription at and here, for free, on our website and Facebook.

But when a large portion of our regular revenue has disappeared due to so many other businesses being closed, our circulation being affected by the same issue, and all of our specials canceled until the end of the year, we are looking for alternative ways to keep operations going, staff paid, and the paper out every Friday for you to enjoy.

Please consider a financial contribution to help us keep doing what we do best; telling the stories of our people in a contemporary medium – a solid, continuing archive that documents our cherished, shared history. Your kind donation will go to a newspaper that stands as the historical record, in-depth, informative and award-winning news; colourful stories, and a big boost to the local economy by employing 95 percent local workers.

Also, please consider subscribing to our e-edition, which comes out Thursday night, at today, or pick up your copy Friday morning in Kahnawake, Kanesatake or Chateauguay. Akwesasne delivery has been suspended due to the pandemic and border issues.

We exercise real freedom of the press every single day. Without our reporters fighting for the truth our community would be missing a whole lot of facts, separated from gossip and rumors.

E-transfers are accepted and very much appreciated at: [email protected]